Everett Edward Kelley was born January 8, 1898, in Whitesville, Kentucky, to Charles Alphonzo Kelley and Mary Alice Ralph. His father was a farmer and a service station operator.
Kelley attended medical school at Vanderbilt, where he was a member of Alpha Omega Alpha.[3] He started at guard for Dan McGugin's Vanderbilt football teams from 1922 to 1924. He was a prominent member of Commodores teams that compiled a win–loss–tie record of 20–2–3 (.860) over his three years, and won two conference titles.
The rematch with the Michigan Wolverines at Ferry Field in 1923, saw Michigan win a bitterly fought contest 3 to 0. Michigan went on to have an undefeated season, and is one of the teams to claim a national title in '23. After the game, the referee McDonald approached Kelley and told him, "You are the first individual I've complimented after a game in which I officiated, but I want to tell you that I never saw a better guard than you are."[5] One of the four touchdowns by Gil Reese in the 35 to 7 victory over the Georgia Bulldogs was a 5-yard run behind Kelley. At the end of the year, Kelley was selected for the All-Southern squad.[6] He was elected to captain the Commodores the next year.[5]
1924
The 1924 team, captained by Kelley, was dubbed in Fred Russell's Fifty Years of Vanderbilt Football "the most eventful season in the history of Vanderbilt football." On opening day against Henderson-Brown, Vanderbilt won 13–0. One of Vandy's two scores came on a punt blocked by Kelley, recovered by Hek Wakefield.[7] The third week of play saw the Commodores tie with the Quantico Marines by a score of 13–13. Kelley was injured in this game. He would sit on the bench the rest of the year except for five minutes of the Tulane game the next week.[8]Lynn Bomar suffered a brain hemorrhage in the game against Georgia that year, and in the final game against Sewanee, Wakefield broke his leg. Thus as the season finished, three of Vanderbilt's All-Southern selections for 1923 sat on the bench.