After retiring from baseball, Tenney became a lawyer and the superintendent of schools for Holliston, Massachusetts, before his death on June 15, 1919.
Early life
Tenney was born on July 9, 1859, in Marlborough, New Hampshire, to Henry Clay and Julia C. (née Stebbins) Tenney. Henry served as the principal of Mettowee Academy and the Peterborough, New Hampshire school. Growing up, Tenney had one sibling, Lockhart S. (born November 2, 1865).[1]
In 1884, Tenney began his professional career for the Nationals, where he spent the majority of his 38-game career. Over 32 games with the team, Tenney batted .235 with a triple and 32 runs scored, while playing 27 games in the outfield and six games at first base for the club.[11] He also appeared in four games as a pitcher for the Reds,[6][12] allowing nine earned runs over 35.0 innings pitched. In his only game played for the Quicksteps, Tenney allowed one earned run in a complete game loss.[11] He finished his career with a 2.09 earned run average over 43.0 innings pitched.[11] The following season, Tenney played for the Hartford Babies of the Southern New England League, appearing in three games for the team.[13] Reports indicated that an arm injury may have ended his professional career.[14]
After baseball
After retiring from baseball, Tenney became a lawyer, publishing agent, then principal and superintendent of schools in Holliston, Massachusetts.[2] Tenney died on June 15, 1919, in Fall River, Massachusetts,[15][6] and was interred at Lake Grove Cemetery in Holliston.[11]