Broun ran again in 1992, but lost in the Republican primary to State Senator Mac Collins, 55%–45%. Broun won five of the district's seventeen counties.[9] Collins went on to defeat Ray, 55%–44%.[10]
In 1996, Democratic U.S. Senator Sam Nunn decided to retire. Broun was one of six Republicans who ran for the Republican nomination in the race. Broun finished fourth, with 3% of the vote. Guy Millner, a businessman, finished first with 42% of the vote. He won the run-off election against state representative Johnny Isakson,[11][12] who had received 35% of the vote in the primary,[13] then lost the general election to Democrat Max Cleland by one percentage point.[14]
In February 2007, Republican U.S. Congressman Charlie Norwood, of Georgia's 10th congressional district, died of cancer. Broun had announced his candidacy before Norwood's death. There was a special election open primary in June 2007, where candidates of all parties participated in the primary. A candidate needed 50% to win outright, and there would be a run-off if no candidate earned it the first time. Ten candidates filed: six Republicans, three Democrats, and a Libertarian. State Senator Jim Whitehead was the only candidate with electoral experience, and was considered the frontrunner. He was endorsed by U.S. Senator Saxby Chambliss.
In the primary, Whitehead finished first with 44% of the vote. Broun qualified for the run-off, ranking second with 21% of the vote, with only 198 votes more than third-place finisher James Marlow, a Democrat. Broun won a plurality of just four counties: Oconee (47%), Jackson (42%), Oglethorpe (37%), and Morgan (31%).[15][16]
In the runoff campaign, Whitehead angered some voters by failing to appear at a debate held in Athens and then by referring to his alma mater, the University of Georgia, as a "liberal bastion" that should be eliminated, save for the football team.[17] In the July 17, 2007 election, Broun upset Whitehead by a margin of just 0.8%, a difference of just 394 votes. After the votes were certified, Whitehead declined to ask for a recount despite the narrow margin.[17] Broun won the counties in the Northern part of the district, while Whitehead won the counties in the southern part. Broun's best two performing counties were Clarke (90%) and Oconee (88%).[18]
Broun was challenged by Republican state representative and House Majority Leader Barry Fleming, who had endorsed Whitehead in the 2007 election. Broun defeated Fleming in the July 2008 primary, 71%–29%. He won every county in the district. However, his weakest performance was in the Southeastern part. He won counties like Richmond with just 52% and Columbia with just 58%.[19] He won the general election with 61% to 39% against Democrat Bobby Saxon.[20]
In November 2011, Republican Mac Collins, who had represented much of the middle portion of Broun's redrawn district in Congress a decade earlier, said he was likely to challenge Broun in the 10th District.[23] In May 2012, Collins decided he would not challenge Broun.[24]
In July, Broun won the Republican primary, defeating retired Army officer Stephen Simpson. Broun faced no Democratic candidate in the November general election.[25]
A leaked video of a speech given at Liberty Baptist Church Sportsman's Banquet on September 27, 2012, shows Broun telling supporters that, "All that stuff I was taught about evolution and embryology and the Big Bang Theory, all that is lies straight from the pit of Hell."[26] In addition, Broun is a young earth creationist, and believes that the world is only a few thousand years old, and was created in six literal days. In response to these remarks, coupled with Broun being on the House Science Committee, libertarian radio talk show host Neal Boortz spearheaded a campaign to run the English naturalist and evolutionary theorist Charles Darwin against Broun, with the intention of drawing attention to these comments from the scientific community and having Broun removed from his post on the House Science Committee.[27]
Broun won re-election on November 6, 2012, receiving 209,917 votes across the district. Charles Darwin received about 4000 write-in ballots in Athens-Clarke County as protest votes against Broun's views on evolution, while Broun received 16,980 votes in that county.[28][29]
In 2016, Broun announced his candidacy for Congress. By this time, he had moved to Gainesville, which is in the Georgia's 9th congressional district. At the time, Cook Political Report rated the 9th as the third most conservative district in the nation.[30] He was running mostly in territory that he did not know and that did not know him, though he represented the district's share of Athens for much of his first stint in Congress.
Broun ran in a five-candidate Republican primary race with fellow Tea Party challengers Roger Fitzpatrick, Bernie Fontaine and Mike Scupin, against incumbent candidate Doug Collins, who held the 9th since 2012. In the May primary, Collins won with 52,943 votes (61.3 percent of the vote), over Broun's 18,761 votes (22 percent), Fitzpatrick's 8,942 votes (10.5 percent), Scupin's 2,854 votes (3.36 percent), and Fontaine's 2,338 votes (2.75 percent).[31]
Broun strongly opposed the Affordable Care Act ("ACA" or "Obamacare) and supported efforts to repeal and defund the health care reform legislation.[50] Broun supported the October 2013 U.S. federal government shutdown, which was precipitated by a group of Republican members of Congress who sought to dismantle the ACA.[50] In 2009, Broun proposed alternate health care legislation that would involve a 100% tax deduction of healthcare costs, allowing consumers to shop for health insurance across state lines, and the privatization of Medicare.[51]
Broun has argued for continued U.S. support of Israel on both strategic and theological grounds, saying in 2014, "It's absolutely imperative that we support Israel—our brothers and sisters in the Middle East—not only because of the geopolitical reasons there, which are strong enough in themselves, but because of a promise God made to Abraham."[54]
2020 AR-15 campaign ad video controversy
A video released by Broun's campaign in 2020 showed Broun shooting a rifle, offering to give away an AR-15 rifle "to one lucky person who signs up for email updates" from his campaign website, and warning that during the COVID-19 pandemic that Americans might need an AR-15 to shoot "looting hordes from Atlanta."[55] Broun lives in Gainesville, a white majority city about an hour outside the state capital Atlanta, which is a majority African American city.[55] Broun denied that the ad or the reference to "looting hordes from Atlanta" had racial undertones or might concern African-Americans.[55]
In February 2013, Broun officially announced he would leave his house seat[57] to run for the open senate seat vacated by Republican U.S. Senator Saxby Chambliss. Broun finished fifth in the May Republican primary.[3]
Personal life
Broun has three children and two grandchildren.[58][59][60]
^David Lightman (January 12, 2015). "Republican Party will test Christian voters' clout". McClatchy Washington Bureau. opponents in primaries who had strong Christian-right support, such as ... Paul Broun in Georgia.
^Charles S. Bullock III; Mark Caleb Smith (1997). "Georgia: Purists, Pragmatists, and Electoral Outcomes". In Mark J. Rozell; Clyde Wilcox (eds.). God at the Grass Roots, 1996: The Christian Right in the American Elections. Rowman & Littlefield. p. 52. One method by which to approximate the size of the Christian Right is to examine votes for candidates who it is believed drew almost exclusively on the evangelical community for support, such as Paul Broun, a U.S. Senate candidate in the GOP primary.
^"Biography // About Me". Congressman Paul Broun, M.D. Broun.house.gov. Archived from the original on October 14, 2013. Retrieved November 29, 2012. Dr. Broun has been married to his wife Niki since 1985 and has two grown daughters, a son and two grandchildren.